Pt. 1 - Appearance and Zoom Range
Pt. 2 - JPEG Noise
Pt. 3 - ISO 80 JPEG Crops at 35mm & Full Aperture
Pt. 4 - Flare Performance
Pt. 5 - Noise Performance Revisited
Pt. 6 - G7 Default JPEG vs GX100 Silkypix Conversions
Pt. 7 - Key Timings
Pt. 8 - Build Quality, Quality Control, and Battery Life
Pt. 9 - Conclusion
Disclaimer: This section, while important, is extremely subjective. All I can tell you is of my experience with a small number of samples of these cameras.
D-LUX 2
Build Quality - The D-LUX 2 build is very nice with a light but solid feel. It has a metal body with only limited use of plastic.
Quality Control - The one copy I have tried of the D-LUX 2 has been flawless.
GX100
Build Quality - The GX100 build quality is also very nice. It also has a great, solid feel. Both copies I have owned have had wobbly lens assemblies, which perceptibly shift even when the camera is inverted a certain way with the lens assembly retracted. The zoom control on my second copy also has a bit of an inconsistent click, which is a minor issue but worth mentioning.
Quality Control - The first unit I bought was purchased new but had signs of use. I cannot say for sure that it had been used and returned, but I suspect that it was. At any rate, that camera did not function properly. It may be that the original owner dropped it or damaged it in some way, so I want to be careful not to say much about Ricoh QC based on the one unit. The second unit, incidentally purchased from a different seller, has been perfect.
G7
Build Quality - The G7 build feels the most solid of the three. While the D-LUX 2 may look more luxurious (especially to "Red Dot" fans), and the GX100 may feel more luxurious, the G7 definitely feels the most substantial of the three. It is by far the heaviest. Even the battery and card door mechanisms feel durable, which I can't say for the other two cameras.
Quality Control - Unfortunately it took me three tries to get a good G7. The first one I bought new had multiple white hot pixels in the center of the sensor, apparent even on very short exposures. The second came with signs of use, large debris (not just dust) inside the front lens element, and at least 5-6 stuck or dead LCD pixels (I don't go looking for these and in general am not troubled by them). The third has a couple sensor pixels stuck on blue, but I am not troubled by them. Much better than white. The other thing I noticed is that the amount of viewfinder inaccuracy was not the same on the three G7 units. The third had less parallax error than the second. I should mention that the "good" G7 was purchased from a different store than the first two.
Since I don't feel that I can draw any solid conclusions based on these few experiences, I won't say here where I bought the units that had problems. I will say that the sellers involved were prompt and professional in issuing refunds or exhanges as requested.
Battery Life
I will report here my subjective findings since I don't plan to do any formal testing. Battery life is not a strong point for any of these three cameras. Compared to my previous compact camera, a Fujifilm Finepix F30, all three of the currently compared cameras have poor battery life. Compared to one another, the G7 seems a bit better than the other two. Subjectively, I get a full day of intermittent shooting with one G7 charge, whereas the GX100 and D-LUX 2 have me turning to spare batteries part of the way through the day. With any of these cameras, an extra battery or two will be needed if you plan to do a lot of shooting.
GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 8 - Build Quality, Quality Control, and Battery Life
Wednesday, June 20, 2007
Posted by Amin
Labels:
battery life,
build quality,
Canon,
D-LUX 2,
G7,
GX100,
quality control,
Ricoh
GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 8 - Build Quality, Quality Control, and Battery Life
2007-06-20T14:22:00-05:00
Amin
battery life|build quality|Canon|D-LUX 2|G7|GX100|quality control|Ricoh|
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Recent Posts
-
►
2009
(119)
-
►
October
(10)
- Adobe Lightroom 3 Beta Noise Reduction
- 'Best Camera' iPhone Application
- Serious Use of Compact Camera Images in Graphic De...
- Sunday Thoughts about Gear Obsession
- Real-life ISO 1600: Panasonic GH1, G1, and Canon S...
- Canon S90 Barrel Distortion
- Canon Powershot S90 IS Initial Impressions: Build ...
- Canon S90 Now In Stock at Some Stores
- Illustration: Multi-Aspect Four Thirds Versus Stan...
- Micro Four Thirds Camera Comparison Table
-
►
September
(19)
- GRD III Impressions / Review at Wouter Brandsma Ph...
- Face Detection
- Panasonic Lumix 20mm f/1.7 Review at DPReview
- Featured Photographer: Vern Dewit
- Sigma DP2 Shootout Supplement: Bokeh
- Sigma DP2 Shootout Pt. 3 - Dynamic Range
- New Site for Micro Four Thirds Reviews
- The End of an Era
- Sigma DP2 Shootout Pt. 2 - Detailed Scene
- Short Ricoh GR Digital 3 impression
- 2010 Micro Four Thirds Lens Roadmap: What's Missin...
- Sigma DP2 Shootout Pt. 1 - Form and Function
- Update on the Sigma DP2 - Olympus E-P1 Shootout
- E-P1 - GH1 Size Comparison
- Leica M9 ISO Test at Focus Numerique
- Leica X1: A Digital Hexar AF?
- Direct View Interchangeable Lens (DVIL): The Devil...
- Which Micro Four Thirds: A Personal Rationalizatio...
- It's Official: Panasonic GF1
-
►
August
(9)
- GH1 - G1 ISO Comparison, RAW + JPEG Night Scene by...
- Powershot S90: Canon Pioneers Free Lunch
- New Canons Now Available for Pre-Order
- Canon reveals new prosumer cameras
- OT: Tamron AF 60mm f/2.0 SP DI II LD IF 1:1 Macro ...
- S.C. Hall of Fame: Canon PowerShot A95
- Five Reasons I'm Excited About the Rumoured Panaso...
- Panasonic GF1
-
►
October
(10)
-
▼
2007
(79)
-
▼
June
(17)
- Move Over Venus III, Here Comes Lightroom 1.1
- Adobe Lightroom 1.1 Adds GX100 Support and More
- "Bodies will come and go. Buy the best glass you ...
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 9 - Conclusi...
- Cases for the G7, GX100, and D-LUX 2
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 8 - Build Qu...
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 7 - Key Timi...
- PhotographyBLOG GX100 Review
- GX100 vs. G7 Shootout Pt. 6 - G7 Default JPEG vs G...
- A Day in NYC with the GX100
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 5 - Noise Pe...
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 4 - Flare Pe...
- Full Size GX100 Sample Photos and Video Posted at ...
- GX100 vs LX2 photos posted by Björn Utpott (viztyg...
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 3 - ISO 80 J...
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 2 - JPEG Noi...
- GX100 vs. G7 vs. D-LUX 2 Shootout Pt. 1 - Appearan...
-
▼
June
(17)









